Depositphotos 147061913 xl 2015

REAL MUM TALK

Why are so many mums still made to feel guilty about having an epidural?

· 6 min read

Words: Laura Cooke

Sometimes pregnancy can feel like one massive nine month-long guilt trip.

During those 40 weeks the questions flow thick and fast: Am I exercising enough? Should I have eaten that? Did I accidentally just inhale too much secondhand smoke from that man walking past me on the other side of the road?

Meanwhile, everyone seems to have an opinion on what you should be doing and how you should be doing it. And they have absolutely no hesitation in letting you know if they think you aren’t doing it right.

Most mums will have been on the receiving end of some sort of judgemental behaviour during their pregnancy.

But instead of being united by this universal experience, we can find ourselves pitted against other mothers when it comes to the topic of pain relief in labour.

Recent figures show that around 30 percent of birthing women have an epidural or spinal, an injection delivered to the back to cause numbness below the waist.

Yet despite being a popular pain relief option, a stigma still exists surrounding the use of epidurals in labour.

The fear of failure and epidural guilt

Many mums find themselves grappling with so-called ‘epidural guilt’. There is a strange idea that asking for this particular form of pain relief means you have failed in some way, or that you are not having the full birthing experience.

Mum-of-two Victoria Myerscough who blogs at www.semicharmedlife.co.uk said: “I had inductions with both of mine, had an epidural with my son, and two failed epidurals with my daughter. “I’ve always felt a bit guilty for having an epidural and I don’t know why, I certainly don’t judge anyone else for it.”

After baby photographer Rachel Murphy gave birth, she struggled with the notion that she had failed by turning to this particular method of pain relief. She said: “I ended up having an epidural and emergency cesarean with my first. I remember crying as I agreed to it and apologising to my husband for not managing it naturally. Of course, it was completely necessary but at the time I felt like I had failed.”

Claudia Fumagalli, who runs personalised children’s card stores Superfumi, had an epidural during both her labors. She said: “The first time round I felt robbed of the ‘natural birth’ I had my mind set on; I wanted the pool, all of it. I did feel like justifying myself to people afterward but once some time passed I realised the epidural actually allowed me to have a very peaceful and lovely birth, with only one midwife and my husband present. Second time around I asked for it as soon as I could and felt pretty unapologetic for it.”

Why is a natural birth still a badge of honour?

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for real mum chat and tips to make life that little bit easier

We have been fed this idea that a ‘natural birth’, that is one without drugs or medical intervention, is the holy grail. It is seen as a badge of honour that you have suffered, that you have sacrificed yourself for your child.

But pain endurance is such a strange thing to boast about. Would you brag about undergoing a tooth extraction without anesthetic? And there is no hard evidence to suggest that a so-called ‘natural’ birth makes you a better mum. If you gave birth in a fog of painkillers and numb from the waist down, it doesn’t make you any less of a mother than the woman in the next bed who managed it on just a whiff of lavender oil.

READ NEXT: I developed PTSD after having a baby at 28 weeks

The benefits of an epidural

Nurse Holly Wakefield, who has 12 years experience specialising in early pregnancy and gynaecology at the Royal Berkshire Hospital, said: “Epidurals are great for those experiencing an especially painful or long labour with minimal side effects to baby, whereas other pain medication may leave you feeling drowsy and sick. They also allow patients to be awake and comfortable during assisted deliveries such as forceps, ventouse and c-section.”

“Some birthing women may perceive it as a negative thing. Some feel that it takes away from the experience of childbirth. There are also several myths around epidurals such as they cause permanent paralysis (very, very rare) and chronic back ache (they don’t).”

The Nice (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) guidelines say that women should be able to have an epidural any time they want one, including during the early stages of labour.

But despite this, evidence has emerged that some health trusts are continuing to perpetuate the potentially harmful myth that a ‘natural’ birth is best, regardless of personal circumstances.

Are women being denied epidurals?

A Sunday Telegraph investigation in January claimed that some women were being denied epidurals because of what it called a “cult of natural childbirth” in some NHS trusts. And in February, University Hospitals Bristol NHS Trust was forced to withdraw ‘dangerous’ advice to women on how to achieve a ‘normal’ birth, which included avoiding epidurals.

But we all know there is no such thing as a ‘normal’ birth. No two labours are the same, hence the notion that a ‘one size fits all’ approach to childbirth isn’t appropriate. But used in this context it also suggests that having an epidural is an abnormal thing, which of course it isn’t.

“I wanted an epidural and was laughed at by the midwife who thought I was joking because they didn’t believe I was in full labour.” explains Stephanie Womble Kenyon. “Thankfully the anaesthesist came quickly and was really insistent I was checked. I was already crowning,” she adds.

Mum of one Leann was also denied an epidural at first. “I was induced and was in extreme pain because the way my son was lying on my hip. I asked for an epidural and was told to suck it up. I was told all the bad things that could happen because of it. I ended up having an emergency c section.”

These are examples of birthing women being shamed by medical professionals and potentially being coerced into doing something they may not be entirely happy with. Also, the danger with being refused an epidural, or refusing to have one, means difficult labour could become a traumatic one if the pain isn’t controlled appropriately, potentially putting mum at risk of PTSD or postnatal depression.

Women are constantly told what they can and can’t do with their own bodies and the one place we should be able to state clearly what we want, without fear of judgement, is in the delivery suite. Having an epidural doesn’t make you less of a woman or less of a mother. It does not make you abnormal. It is just a form of pain relief to help you through one of the most extreme things your body will ever go through. And hopefully make the experience just that bit easier.

If you are a mum who got through labour by using breathing techniques or essential oils, then I applaud you. If you had every drug going, kudos to you. If your undercarriage looked like the aftermath of a small explosion, well done for coming out the other side. C-Section? Wear those battle scars with pride. You all did a great job.

And as nurse Holly Wakefield says: “It is down to individual opinion and what you think will work for you.

“I should also mention that whilst you can write the world’s best birthing plan, it rarely ends up the way you planned!”

READ NEXT: We asked 20 women how long they took to have sex after having a baby

ENDS

the CONVERSATION

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *